Is Airbnb a Good Investment? The Kitchen Table Conversation First
Sixty three percent. In the Federal Reserve's latest survey of household finances, that's the share of adults who said they'd cover a surprise four hundred dollar expense with cash, savings, or a credit card they pay off at the next statement. Flip it around, and more than a third of adults would not cover it that way.
Welcome back to the Cashflow Diary podcast. I'm J. Massey.
Keep that number in mind and picture a kitchen table. You've been reading about short term rentals for weeks. You finally say it out loud. What if we did an Airbnb? And the person across from you asks one question. What happens when the water heater goes, and nobody's booked?
That question is the whole episode. Today is about whether Airbnb is a good investment for your household, and the five numbers to put on the table before any money moves. Two quick notes before we start. This is education, not legal, tax, or financial advice. And any number that isn't from a published source is a made up example, so you can follow the math.
One of the things people tell us often is that a spouse or partner is against the idea, or worried about debt, or not convinced. Most of the time that worry is a fair one, and it points at a real number.
Back in twenty nineteen, on one of our live Q and A calls, a host was walking me through a rough stretch with their rentals. One of the first things I asked was whether their significant other was around. I said, I always love hearing first party what their concerns specifically are. I still feel that way. The person who's worried usually knows exactly which number scares them.
So before the five numbers, one rule for the conversation. In our trainings I teach something I call the seventy thirty rule. The other person talks seventy percent of the time, while you're taking notes and asking questions the other thirty. I teach it for sales calls. It works at the kitchen table too. Let your partner list every worry first. Write each one down. Most of them will line up with one of the five numbers.
Number one. The all in cost. This is every dollar that leaves your account before the first guest checks in.
Furniture. Linens and towels, usually more than one set. Kitchen gear. Locks, smoke and carbon monoxide alarms, first aid kit. Photos. Software. If you're renting the place, add the deposit and the first month's rent. If you're buying, add the down payment and closing costs.
Let's use a made up number. Say the all in cost for a furnished one bedroom comes to fourteen thousand dollars. Write it down as one line, in ink. Your partner should see the real total, as one number.
A big total shows up here. Better that it shows up on paper than on a credit card statement three months from now.
Number two. The reserve. This is money you set aside and don't touch, for the month that goes wrong.
In one of my trainings on renting to rent, I said, you've got to watch yourself. You want to make sure you have adequate reserves. That was about not growing too fast, but it starts with unit number one.
Think back to the Federal Reserve number. More than a third of adults said they would not cover four hundred dollars with cash or its equivalent. A rental will hand you a four hundred dollar surprise. A dishwasher. A lockout. A guest who breaks something. If your household is already in that third, the reserve comes first, before furniture.
For this example, say your fixed costs are about twenty four hundred fifty dollars a month. Rent, utilities, internet, supplies. Three months of that is about seventy four hundred dollars. Add it to the all in cost, and the made up household needs about twenty one thousand four hundred dollars available before the first booking. That's the real number for the kitchen table.
Number three. A realistic net. This is what's left after everyone else gets paid.
Start with what guests pay. Airbnb's own resource center says that in twenty twenty six it moved to a single service fee of fifteen and a half percent, paid by hosts, with some exceptions. That fee applies to your nightly price and any fees you add, like cleaning, and it's taken out before your payout.
Made up example. In a normal month, guests pay forty five hundred dollars. The fifteen and a half percent fee is about seven hundred. Your payout is about thirty eight hundred. Now take out rent at two thousand, utilities and internet at three hundred, supplies at a hundred fifty, and cleaning at five hundred. That leaves about eight hundred fifty dollars.
Eight hundred fifty dollars in a normal month, in a made up example, before taxes. That's the number to say at the table. Gross bookings sound exciting, and your partner will trust you more when you lead with the smaller number.
Number four. The downside month. Every market has one.
On that same twenty nineteen call, I talked about my own market in California. I said the first two weeks of December, sometimes the first three weeks depending on how it falls, are horrible. Every market has its own version of that month. Find out which one yours is before you sign anything.
Run the made up numbers again for a slow month. Guests pay two thousand dollars. The fee is about three hundred ten, so your payout is about sixteen ninety. Rent, utilities, and supplies still come to twenty four fifty, and you clean less, say two fifty. That's about a thousand dollars out of pocket that month.
This is the number your partner is really asking about. Show it to them. Then show them that the reserve covers seven months like that. With a reserve sized for it, that thousand dollars was planned for before the month started.
Number five. Time per week. This one costs no money, and it's the one that gets left off the page.
Messages, cleaner scheduling, restocking, pricing, reviews, the call when a guest can't get in. Some of that can be automated or handed off later. In the first months, most of it lands on you.
I won't give you a number for this one, because I don't have a published one for your situation. Each of you writes down a guess. How many hours a week, and which hours. Weeknights? Saturday mornings? Then compare. If one of you wrote two hours and the other wrote ten, that gap is the conversation.
And ask the question your partner is probably thinking. Whose hours are these? If the answer is, mostly yours, say so. If the answer is, both of us, put names next to the jobs.
Now the choice that changes all five numbers. Owning the property, or renting a place and hosting it with the owner's permission, what people call rental arbitrage.
Owning means a down payment, a mortgage, and a home that can lose value. Renting to rent means a smaller all in cost, but a lease you owe every month whether guests come or not, and a landlord who has to agree in writing. In one of my trainings I put it this way. A twelve month risk, I don't care how you put it, is always cheaper than a thirty year mortgage. That's my view, and a twelve month lease is still a real commitment. Run the five numbers for both and compare.
Either way, check the rules before you count on any income. Read your city or county code on short term rentals, call the permit office, read the H O A rules if there are any, and read the lease. Airbnb also asks hosts to learn their local rules. Bring what you find to the table, and if something's unclear, ask a local attorney.
One more line from my own trainings. You do your first deals for experience, not profit, and then later you get to profit from your experience. Your partner may find that easier to hear than a forecast.
Before you leave the table, agree on two things.
First, the most you're willing to lose. That's usually the all in cost plus a few downside months. Say it as one dollar amount, and make sure you both said yes to it.
Second, a stop rule. Something like, if we lose money three months in a row, we sit down and decide whether to keep going. Write it on the same page as the five numbers. A stop rule tells a worried partner there's a point where the experiment ends, and that you'll both decide it together.
Then the questions partners ask most. What's the most we could lose? Whose name is on the lease or the loan? What happens to our savings? How many hours is this? What happens if nobody books? Every one of those has an answer on your page now.
Sixty three percent. That number from the top was about a four hundred dollar surprise. At your kitchen table, the question was the water heater and the empty calendar. Now you've got an answer to bring back. The all in cost, the reserve, a realistic net, the downside month, and the hours.
Your homework. Thirty minutes, one sheet of paper, both of you. Write the five numbers, use made up figures where you don't have real ones yet, and circle the one that worries each of you most.
And remember, a rental business takes work, it takes money, and it can lose money. These five numbers help you decide together. They don't guarantee a result.
If you'd like help pressure testing your five numbers for your own market, that's what our complimentary one-on-one diagnostic call is for. Go to cashflowdiary.com/diagnostic. Bring the sheet of paper.
Okay, that's it for today. I'm J. Massey. And this has been the Cashflow Diary podcast.
If this helped, rate the show on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. That helps another person find it.
Quick note... this episode was voiced with my licensed AI voice, built from my own recordings.
